Two-Year Study on Effectiveness of Graphing Calculators Released
Results are in from a two-year randomized control trial on the effectiveness of graphing calculators on Algebra and Geometry achievement. Two reports are now available for this project, which was sponsored by Texas Instruments. In year 1 we contrasted business as usual in the math classes of two California school districts with classes equipped with sets of graphing calculators and led by teachers who received training in their use. In the second year we contrasted calculator-only classrooms with those also equipped with a calculator-based wireless networking system.
The project tracked achievement through state and other standardized test scores and implementation through surveys and observations. For the most part, the experiment could not discern an impact as a result of providing the equipment and training for the teachers. Data from surveys and observations make clear that the technology was not used extensively (and by some, not at all) suggesting that training, usability, and alignment issues must be addressed in adoption of this kind of program. There were modest effects, especially for Geometry, but these were often not found consistently for the two measurement scales. In one case contradictory results for the two school districts suggests that researchers should use caution in combining data from different settings.